Alexander Barclay’s Heirs, the 2nd Family: Anna Elizabeth Barclay Carter

Anna Elizabeth Barclay Carter is a sister of Alexander Barclay and his heir.  Anna was born on the 15 of April, 1870 in Eagle Creek.  She is present in the Federal and state census of 1870, 1875, 1880, 1885.  She is also the youngest child of John Barclay and his second wife Ellen.

She married David Maurice Carter on 9 July, 1885 in Scott Co., Minnesota.

Marriage Announcement for Anna & David.

Marriage Announcement for Anna & David.

Married – At Eagle Creek, July 9, 1885, by F.P. Pond Esq. Mr. David Carter to Miss Anna Barclay, youngest daughter of Mr. John Barclay of Eagle Creek. – Shakopee Courier July 15, 1885.

Carter, David, Anna Barclay, July 9, 1885, Book E, page 196 Scott Co. Marriages, Minnesota. 

Marinette and Menominee

Marinette, Wisconsin and Menominee, Michigan

Anna and David Carter lived in an area of Wisconsin which is right on the border of Michigan so you might see to two towns intertwined in the records of people who lived in this area.  These towns are on the shores of Lake Michigan and protected by Green Bay Harbor.  I have seen Lake Michigan but only from its very southern tip.  It is more like an ocean.

Be advised that I am not an expert on the Carter family which looks like it has very interesting history being of French Canadian origins.  There are cousins who know more and what I present here is just a summary so if you want to obtain further information leave a comment and I can contact you to chat.  I am also basing this information on what the census is revealing and cemetery information, more needs to be done.

In 1900 Anna and David Carter appear in the Marinette, Marinette Co., Wisconsin census.  It looks like a brother is nearby?

Line 27, 826, 125, 149, David Carter, Marinette Ward 2, Marinette, Wisconsin, age 35, born about 1865, birthplace Canada French, Spouse is Annie E., White, immigrated 1870. Annie. E. Carter age 30, Marey L. Carter age 12, David W. Carter age 8, Joseph Carter age 4, Frederick A. Carter age 1.

Line 21, 828, 124, 148, Joseph Carter, Head, W, M, June 1864, age 35, married 4, Canada Fr. Immigrated 1868, 52, Na. Woodsman Canada French, born about 1865. Carter, Marey, wife, W, F, May 1872, 28, 4, 3, 3, born Switzerland, parents born Switzerland, immigrated 1882, 18, Carter, Henry, Son, W, M, born Jan 1897, 3, S. Carter, Earl, son, W, M, born Nov. 1898, 1, S.. Carter, George, son W, M, born April 1900 2/12, S. Fageuchau, Adeline, Servant, W, F, born June 1885, 14, S, born Michigan, parents Norway, Servant. 

Source:  1900 U.S. Federal Census, Marinette, Marinette Co., Wisconsin, SD#8, ED#114, Sht #9, enumerated 6 June 1900, by Charles Bell. 

In 1910 Annie and David Carter are living in Marinette, Marinette Co., Wisconsin.  His job looks very interesting in the place he works at.

page 1, Line 98, 2050, 193, 202, Carter, David, Head, M, W, 50, M1, 25, born Wisconsin, parents born Canada French, All English, Engineer, Insane Asylum, W, No, O, Yes, yes, O, M, H, 12, 9, 7 X, Carter, Anna E. Wife, F, W, 40, M1, 25, 13 children born, 9 living, born Minnesota, father Scot, Scottish, mother Nor. Norwegian, none, yes, yes.

Carter, John J., son, M, W, 20, S,born in Wisconsin, father born Wisconsin, mother Minnesota, Knitter, Knitting Mills, W, yes, O, Yes, yes, No. 1 – 0 – 7 6.

Page 2 Sht 11A, all born Wisconsin
line 1, 193, 202, Carter, William D., son, M, W, 18, S, Gloves Factory, W, No., O, Yes, Yes, No. Carter, Joseph M., son, M, W, 14, S, yes, yes, yes. Carter, Frederick A., son, M, W, 11, S, yes, yes, yes. Carter, Leo B., son M, W, 9, S, yes, Carter, Rose, C, daughter, F, W, 8 S, yes. Carter, Grace L., daughter, F, W, 5, S, yes. Carter, Fransis A., son, M, W, 3, S, no. 

Source:  1910 U.S. Federal Census, Marinette, Marinette, Wisconsin, SD#8, ED#81, Sht #10B, Sht 11A, 2 Southside, April 25, 1910, Joseph G. McCailiffe

We find them again in 1920 in Marinette.

Line 26, 2350, 269, 301, Carter, David, Head, O, F, M, W, 65, M, 1860 Na, Unknown, no, no, Canada, French, Canada, French, yes, engineer, factory, W. 
Carter, Anna E, wife, F, W, 49, M, yes, yes, Minnesota, Scotland, English, Norway, Norwegian, yes, none.
Carter, Rose, daughter, F, W, 17, S, No, yes, yes, Wisconsin, all children French, yes, maid, private family, W. Carter, Grace L, daughter, F, W, 15, S, yes,yes, yes, Wisconsin, yes, none
Carter, David, Jr., son, M, W, 8, S, yes, Wisconsin, yes, none

Source:  1920 U.S. Federal Census for Marinette, Marinette Co., Wisconsin, 2nd Precint, SD#8, ED#190, Sht #14A, Ward 2, 9 and 10th January, 1920, Carl. E, Peterson.

They continue to live in Marinette in the 1930 census. They have a daughter and granddaughters living with them at this time.

Line 39, 2050, 442, 548, Carter, David, Head, $5000, R, yes, M, W, 75, M, 30, No, Yes, French Canada, Canada, French, 1860 Nat. yes, Truck farming, farming.
Carter, Anna E, wife, X, F, W, 60 M, 15, No, yes, Minnesota, father Scotland, mother Norway
Carter, Leo B., son, X, M,W, 29, S, No, yes, Wisconsin, yes, Farming, farming
Carter, David F. son, X, M, W, 19, S, No, Yes, Wisconsin, laborer, farming
Kapaun, Grace, daughter, X, F, W, 25, D, 20, No, yes, Wisconsin
Kapaun, Lucille, g daughter, X, F, W, 5, S, No., Wisconsin
Kapaun, Rita, g daughter, X F, W, 3, S, No, Wisconsin

Source:  1930 U.S. Federal Census, Marinette, Marinette Co., Wisconsin, Second Ward, ED#38-12, SD#6, Sht #20A, April 21, 1930 by Eleaear C. Hanson.

In 1940 Anna is a widow now but she has several children still living with her. She has moved southwest of Marinette.

Line 12, 159, 0, 300, yes, Carter, Anna E, Head, F, W, 69, Wd, No, I, born Minnesota, all same house. 
Carter, Leo. B. son, M,W, 39, S, No, 6, Wisconsin, farm, farm, income 28
Carter, William D. son, M,W, 48, D, No, H1, Wisconsin, farm hand, income 50
Carter, David F. son, M,W, 29, S, No, 5, Wisconsin, truck driver, income 100

Source:  1940 U.S. Federal Census, Peshtigo, Marinette, Wisconsin, SD#8, ED#38-29, Sht, #9A, Enumerated June 7, 1940, by Ralph Stawdenmain.

Anna and David Carter had 13 children of which 9 were living in 1900.  I only have 12 children. The following should be followed out in the census to get a better picture of their lives and of course, more research to get a better picture.

1.  Marey L. Carter she was born December 1887 in Michigan and died about 1901 in Menominee, Michigan.  She is buried in the Riverside Cemetery in Menominee.  Marey appears in the 1900 census.

2.  John J. Carter was born about 1890 in Michigan and died May 1975 in Peshtigo. He is also buried in the Riverside Cemetery in Menominee.  He appears in the 1910 census.

3.  David W. Carter born about 1892.  He appears in the 1900 census.

4.  William D. Carter, was born 16 February 1892 in Wisconsin.  He died 3 November 1969 at Rice Lake, Barron, Wisconsin.  He is buried in the Nora Cemetery in Rice Lake. He married Myrtle N. born 20 January 1892 and died 3 December, 1977 at Rice Lake.  She is also buried in Nora Cemetery.

5.  Elizabeth Susan Carter, born about 1894 in Marinette.  I don’t have much on this child.

6.  Joseph Maurice Carter born 25 March 1896 in Marinette, Wisconsin. He married Maude Marie Martin born 31 May, 1898, Thompson, Winnebago, Iowa. They had about eleven children:  Maurice, Arthur, Aurora, Gertrude, Douglas, Mary Ann, Richard, Joseph, Norma, John and maybe another.

Joseph and Maude are buried in the Kristiansand Cemetery, Tioga, Williams Co., North Dakota. Joseph died 1 August, 1955 in Sidney, Richland Co., Montana. Maud died 10 June 1936 in White Earth, Montrail, North Dakota. Find A Grave has their tombstone with information.  Maude’s parents were John Calvin Martin and Mary Ann Caroline Riedel.

7.  Frederick A. Carter was born September 1898 in Wisconsin.

8.  Leo Bernhard Carter was born 3 July 1900 in Marinette.

9.  Rose C. Carter was born 1 February 1902 in Marinette. She died in 1910 and is buried in Riverside Cemetery in Menominee.

10.  Grace L. Carter was born 30 April, 1904 in Marinette and died about 1989 in Peshtigo.  She is buried in the Riverside Cemetery.  She married a Frank Kapaun and they had several children.

11. Fransis A. Carter born 24 May 1906 in Marinette and died about 1911. He is buried in the Woodlawn Cemetery in Marinette.

12. David F. Carter born 8 March 1911 in Marinette and died 2 November, 1988 in Milwaukee.  He is buried in the Wood National Cemetery in Milwaukee.

The father, David Maurice Carter died on the 28th February, 1938 in Marinette. He is buried in the Forest Home Cemetery in Marinette.  Anna followed him 17 years later and died 4 August, 1955 in Menominee.  She is buried in the Forest Home Cemetery in Marinette.  Find A Grave has tombstones for them and some of their other children.

I have had the honor of meeting descendants of Anna’s in the past. They have been kind in sharing about their family history. I therefore have presented here my study of this family which needs more work of course.  If you would like to share or learn more leave a comment.

John Barclay’s Two Families

John Barclay, my great great grandfather, was introduced to me by my Aunt Miriam in her family history notes, so I knew about him.  I also had a copy of the book by the city of Pine River, celebrating their first 100 years, and he is mentioned in that book: 

  “…not far from Shakopee where George’s father chose to live “because it reminded him of his native Scotland.”  Apparently the father, John, remarried and had other children…”  

John Barclay had two families.  He was first married to Margaret.  When he married Margaret is not known and where she is buried is also unknown.  She probably died in Connecticut but so far a search of records reveal only one possibility of a Margaret Barclay dying in Enfield in 1848 of about the right age. 

continuing the quote above…” because at the time of Alexander’s death in 1906, there was quite a bit of difficulty in locating all the Barclay heirs from “both families.”” pg. 105 

In my Aunt Miriam’s notes she mentions Alexander’s probate: 

Alex's Probate


My great-uncle Alexander Barclay has been very good to me.  I secured his probate file at some expense from the Dakota County Courthouse in Minnesota and it opened up a very big genealogical door!  

From this first marriage came seven (7) siblings that were listed in Alexander’s estate file.  There wasn’t a will so some of the information is carefully taken from the probate file.  Other information such as census searches and indexes were also used.  I am slowly gathering the facts together on the siblings and will present more at a later time. 

1.  John Avery Barclay born abt 1836, died – unknown.  According to Alex’s estate file he disappeared and was presumed dead as stated in an affidavit of his sister Sarah Agnes. He appears in deeds, land records, and court documents in Silbey Co., Minnesota till about 1880.  He may have gone to California.  John Avery Barclay was probably born in Scotland per census information and other sources but that is not yet proven.  John married Minerva  Parks on 3 July 1865 in Henderson, Sibley Co., Minnesota.  Since John Avery Barclay was considered dead his two children where his heirs and they are mentioned in the estate file.  The couple actually had four children:  

1. John Avery Barclay II born 23 July 1867 in Sibley Co., Minnesota and died 8 March 1951 in Seattle, King Co., Washington.   

2. Sarah Ellen born 29 March 1869 in Sibley Co., Minnesota.   

3 and 4. There were two other children twins: Albert and Alice born 1870 Silbey Co.,  Minnesota but it is looking like they didn’t survive.  Some of this information was supplied by another cousin.  

2.  James A. Barclay born about 1838 in Connecticut, he died about 1906 in Bridgeport, Fairfield Co., Connecticut during the probate process of Alexander’s estate.  He married a Maryanne Stewart and had children.  

3.  Sarah Agnes Barclay born about 1840 in Connecticut.  She married Porter Blinn about 1860 in Connecticut.  He was born about 1842 in Connecticut.  They had 6 children and it looks like they stayed in Newington, Hartford Co. , Connecticut. 

Update:  May 26, 2010 – I was at the Family History Library researching when I discovered that the Sarah that I thought was Sarah Agnes Barclay in the census married to Porter Blinn was the Sarah I should be studying for the Barclay’s.  Turns out she is a Griswold and her father is Henry Griswold.  So back to the drawing board on #3.  This is why it is so important to check other sources like marriages and birth records and not totally trust the census. 

4.  Mary J. Barclay born about 1841 in Connecticut and died 28 March 1917 in Bristol, Hartford Co., Connecticut.  I have her estate file.  She married a Jerome B. Ford and had 3 daughters.  Jerome was born about 1846 in Connecticut. 

5. Alexander A. Barclay was born September 1842 in Hartford, Connecticut and died on 9 December 1905 at the Rochester Hospital for the Insane in Olmsted Co., Minnesota.  He apparently suffered in the end with dementia.  He was only in the hospital about 6 days before he died.  He was buried 17 December 1905 in the Corinithian Cemetery in Farmington, Dakota Co., Minnesota. 

6.  Martha M. Barclay born about 1843 in Connecticut and died around 1920 or later in California.  She married a Jeremiah Ford in about 1859 in Connecticut.  I do not know if Jeremiah and Jerome were brothers.  Martha and Jeremiah had two daughters.  

7.  George Angus Barclay was born 18 August 1844 probably in Connecticut and died on the 28th of October 1898 in Pine River, Cass Co., Minnesota.  George is the subject of our blog and more information will be forthcoming on his life. He married Amarilla Spracklin in 1878 and they had 2 children. 

The second marriage of John Barclay was to Helen in Scott Co., Minnesota.  I have not been able to find their marriage in Minnesota records but it happened prior to 1860 per the census and from this marriage their were four (4) children born. 

8.  Charles Barclay was born about January 1860 in Eagle Creek (Shakopee), Scott Co., Minnesota.  After the death of his mother in 1907 he seems to have moved from Shakopee and might have gone to Minneapolis and died about 1938.  Charles didn’t marry as far as I can determine from census and other documents. 

9.  William Barclay was born about 1863 in Eagle Creek (Shakopee), Scott Co., Minnesota and died 7 Dec 1937 in Gallatin Co., Montana.  He married a Clara E, probably in Minnesota.  She was born about 1859 in Wisconsin and died about 21 March 1919 in Madison Co., Montana.  They had one child name Foster born 1891 and probably died by 1907.  

10.  Mary E. Barclay was born about 1864 in Eagle Creek (Shakopee), Scott Co., Minnesota and died 19 February 1930 in Cascade Co., Montana.  She married Charles B. Clark probably in Minnesota for he was born there about 1856.  He died 28 February 1932 in Deer Lodge Co., Montana.  They had at least one child named Ruth Clark who was born about 1895.   It is interesting that there are two Mary’s named in John’s family a good 20+ years apart. 

11.  Anna Elizabeth Barclay was born 15 April 1870 in Shakopee, Scott Co., Minnesota and died 4 August 1955 in Menominee, Menominee Co., Michigan.  She married David Maurice Carter on 9 July 1885 in Eagle Creek (Shakopee), Scott Co., Minnesota.  David was born 9 January 1860, Marinette, Marinette Co., Wisconsin.  The information for this family was supplied by a cousin and has not been verified.  Anna had 4 children. 

The person that initiated the probate process for Alexander was his niece, my grandmother Grace A. Barclay McDonald.  She was pregnant at the time and lived in International Falls.  She was unable to attend the court sessions because she had the baby and was “indisposed.”  The baby was my Aunt Miriam. 

Book: Logsleds to Snowmobile’s, Pine River Centennial Celebration, 1873-1973, Written by the Citizens of Pine River and edited by Norman F. Clarke, Pine River Centennial Committee, 1979.  A copy is available at the Family History Library.